NightWatch

For the Night of 6 July 2009 

 

China:   Chinese police arrested 1,434 people for participating in rioting in Xinjiang province, official state media says.  Rioting broke out on Sunday, 5 July, in Urumqi, the capital of Xinjiang, and left 156 people dead and more than 815 injured.

 

The unrest spread to Kashgar on Monday, 6 July, where police dispersed more than 200 "rioters" at the main mosque. Demonstrators said they had been demanding justice for two Uighurs killed last month in a fight with ethnic Han Chinese at a factory in Hong Kong.

 

Chinese authorities blame ethnic Muslim Uighurs for the violence, but exiled Uighurs say police fired on students. The representatives of Uighur groups in exile also said the riot was a response to government policies and Han Chinese dominance of the local economy.


The political objective of the Uighurs is increased autonomy of Xinjiang Province and especially an end to the government programs that promote internal migration of Han Chinese into Uighur territory.

The Han Chinese population buildup over time converts the Uighurs from a majority into a minority in their historic territory. Demographic manipulation is a form of political disenfranchisement, first, and genocide, later.

 

As for the Uighurs, the protests have some short term local impact, but have no possibility of stopping the invasion of the Han Chinese. The Uighurs, who are Muslims, have no chance for independence from China and little prospect for increased local autonomy.

 

India:  For the record.  The government published its annual budget today, saying the "first challenge" is to return to a growth rate of 9% a year "at the earliest". Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee said the growth rate for the present fiscal year was projected at 6.7%.

He said the second challenge would be to "deepen and broaden the agenda for inclusive development".  The government increased spending on urban poor schemes and the landmark jobs-for-work scheme to help the poor.

 

Afghanistan-US:  The commander of U.S. and NATO forces in Afghanistan has issued new combat orders intended to reduce Afghan civilian casualties, Reuters reported 6 July, citing an unclassified report describing the changes. General McChrystal said in the report that U.S. and NATO forces must make a shift away from conventional combat and toward winning Afghan support.

 

Some of the changes include new guidelines for air strikes that weigh the need for air support against the directive to avoid civilian casualties and excessive damage on residential compounds, and new training ordered for all U.S. soldiers in Afghanistan.

 

Comment:  NightWatch has been following Afghanistan since 1979, literally since before the day the Soviets invaded. The notion of outreach to Pashtun tribal elders, imams and councils has always sounded eminently practical and reasonable to Westerners. The problem is that Pashtuns do not want outreach or even good “governance” – whatever that means. They are very clear that they want security and will be loyal to whoever provides it.

 

As for Coalition forces, the Pashtuns want them out of Afghanistan. They say so, openly. They do not need Coalition friendship, however, well intended. The window of openness to foreign forces closed five years ago, including to Arabs; the opportunity for good government closed with it.

 

Judging by the increase in the number of wounded Western soldiers in May, the reduction in air support has had the predictable effect of increasing Coalition losses.  During May, 27 allied soldiers were killed and 58 wounded. 

 

May 2009 was the second month of the Taliban summer offensive, which was just beginning to ramp up. May was the worst month for Western causalities since September 2008. In the seven-year history of the conflict, May 2009 ranks as the fourth bloodiest month. 

 

In successful counter-insurgency operations, outreach and cultural sensitivity initiatives make a difference only after secure conditions have been restored, meaning that security problems have been reduced to the level that they can be managed by police or paramilitary police without the assistance of military combat forces.

 

Energy and resources devoted to making friends with Pashtun elders in Helmand are a waste of time unless accompanied by a guarantee of security for more than a few weeks. They will be loyal to whoever can provided reliable protection 24X7 for persons and property all the time. For now that is the Taliban.

 

More importantly, Pashtun elders will and do understand and interpret Coalition initiatives as short term dodges that implicitly admit the Coalition is not able to provide the security that commands their respect and loyalty.  The Coalition is only the latest outside power to make promises that it cannot keep for more than a few months, not the first.

 

Security is what the Taliban offer in over 150 of Afghanistan’s 398 districts. Their leaders know the increased US and other Coalition forces are to help ensure the security of national elections in August. They can out wait them.  Meanwhile, the reduction in air support exacts a high price in Allied casualties on the ground.

 

Concerning Helmand Province, a Taliban representative said 6 July that Taliban militants have launched a guerrilla operation to counter the attack by U.S. Marines on their stronghold in Helmand Province that would teach the Marines "a lesson," Agence France-Presse reported. The representative said, "In response to Operation Khanjar by the invading forces, we have launched Operation Foladi Jal" and "Their Khanjar will get stuck in our Foladi Jal."

 

Saudi Arabia: A foreign ministry spokesman denied a news report claiming the Saudi government had agreed to allow Israeli warplanes to fly through the Kingdom’s airspace to attack Iranian nuclear sites, Agence-France Presse reported 6 July. The spokesman denied the two countries have diplomatic, commercial, or other relations, claiming the report was aimed at fraying Arab unity. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office denied the report on 5 July according to the report.

 

The denials are credible and understandable, especially after the US Vice President’s statement that implied Israel is on its own in an attack against Iran.

 

Somalia-Iran:  The Iranian Navy has dispatched two warships to join international efforts to provide security for shipping in the Gulf of Aden from Somali pirates, Iran's Deputy Naval Commander, Gholam-Reza Khadem, said 6 July, Press TV reported. The two warships will replace older non-combatant ships sent earlier and protect Iranian merchant containers and oil tankers. Khadem said the new deployment is in response to increased pirate attacks on Iranian ships.

 

What prevents the Iranians from quietly helping al Shabaab forces, while also fighting pirates from clans opposed to al Shabaab. The al Shabaab Islamists have never been friendly to pirates and the Iranians are friends of the friends of the Islamists, i.e., Sudan and Eritrea. This bears watching.

 

 

Somalia:  A top leader of al Shabaab said 6 July that the government of Somalia in Mogadishu has five days to hand over all its weapons and surrender, Press TV reported. Al Shabaab commander Sheik Mukhtar Abu Subeyr said his fighters would show no mercy to government officials the group already has in captivity and those the group will capture. Al Shabaab has accused the government of "serving foreign interests."

 

The Mogadishu government rejected the ultimatum and disparaged al Shabaab for making it. Stay tuned. If al Shabaab fighters have the capabilities they profess, they should occupy Mogadishu by this time next week.

 

YOTTABYTES AND THE DATA ANALYSIS CHALLENGE

Extrapolating from current trends, according to a report by the JASON defense analysis group and just recently reported by Stephen Aftergood, data production could hypothetically reach the Yottabyte range by 2015.  The Yotta- prefix means ten raised to the twenty-fourth power.  Mega- means ten to the sixth power, Giga- means ten to the ninth power, and Tera- is ten to the twelfth power.

 

If one byte of data were used to image one square meter of the Earth's surface, then 1.6 Yottabytes would be generated by imaging the entire surface of the Earth every second for a hundred years, according to the December 2008 report by the JASON group.

 

The challenge of performing even superficial analysis of the constantly exploding volume of collected intelligence data is not a new problem.  NSA’s brilliant and only NIO for Warning, David Y McManus, commented over 25 years ago that information could be collected and distributed faster than it could be evaluated. Human analysts remained the weakest and slowest link in the intelligence process, he lamented, because no tools existed in 1983 to facilitate and accelerate analysis.

 

The most troubling immediate question is that with the development of drones that are sensors, reporters of intelligence data and weapons platforms, who does the analysis that enables the drone or drone pilot, sitting sometimes thousands of miles away, to distinguish between a wedding party and an ambush party in the Pashtun regions of Afghanistan and Pakistan. They tend to look a lot alike.  

 

In 2007, multiple agencies of the Department of Defense and the armed services invited bids for at least seven contracts valued at over $1 billion for the development of systems that could perform automatic analysis of the situation just described and others, without humans in the inferential chain.  None of those contracting agencies were intelligence organizations.

 

The machines are under development which will make redundant all “analysts” who perform low grade cognitive functions, as described in Chapter 3 of Thinking in Time, by Neustadt and May.

 

Special thanks to Stephen Aftergood and FAS for spotlighting this problem, which only gets worse.

 

End of NightWatch for 6 July.